The Differences Between Theory X & Theory Y

  • /
  • Blog
  • /
  • The Differences Between Theory X & Theory Y

Motivation is a process in which an individual decides to act or not based on their own desire. It can be defined as "the energy source that drives an individual toward action." In other words, it is the force that makes us move from one state to another. This force can be either positive or negative. For example, we may want to do something because we feel like doing it, or we may want to avoid doing something for fear of punishment.

There are two main theories of motivation – Theory X and Theory Y.

The former assumes that people are motivated primarily by external rewards (money, status etc.), and the latter assumes that they are motivated by internal rewards (achievement, self-esteem).

Douglas McGregor initially created these theories when he worked at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Sloan School of Management in Boston during the 1950s and later expanded upon it in the 1960s.

What is the difference between Theory X and Theory Y?

Both theories are helpful, but each has its limitations. For example, Theory X says that people who don't get enough external rewards will become unmotivated. This means that if you want to motivate someone, you should give them something they value. In contrast, Theory Y suggests that people are intrinsically motivated and continue working even if they don't receive external rewards.

These two theories have a contrasting view of management styles. Theory X managers believe that employees are lazy and don't want to work; therefore, they must be forced into working by their managers. On the contrary, Theory Y managers believe that employees are intrinsically motivated and will work regardless of what happens around them.

They differ in terms of how they view human nature.

Limitations of Theory X

Although this theory emphasizes the importance of meeting people's needs, it does not recognize that people have different needs. This means that some people may not respond well to certain types of motivation.

Another limitation of Theory X is that it ignores the fact that motivation can change over time. In other words, even though you meet an individual's needs today, that might not ensure the person's motivation in the future.

Limitations of Theory Y

This theory focuses more on intrinsic motivation than extrinsic motivation. However, it doesn't consider the fact that people have different motivations at different times. Therefore, it cannot predict what type of motivation people will use in any given situation.

In addition, it fails to acknowledge that people can be motivated by both internal and external factors. Although people may report that they do not care about money (external motivation), this does not mean that they actually don't want to earn enough money!


Customers served! 1

Quality Management Course

FREE! Subscribe to get 52 weekly lessons. Every week you get an email that explains a quality concept, provides you with the study resources, test quizzes, tips and special discounts on our other e-learning courses.

Similar Posts:

August 31, 2021

Difference Between Risk and Hazard

December 3, 2021

PEST and PESTEL Analysis

January 5, 2022

Affinity Diagram

September 4, 2020

Special Cause vs. Common Cause Variation

December 9, 2021

Alternate Project Methodologies

December 3, 2021

Strategic Planning – VMOSA

March 4, 2022

Quotes Against Change

31 Courses on SALE. Join 200,000+ Existing Students.